Evaluation: for terms in GO (already validated terms)

[1] cell division
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 2 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15170211 Yes Yes 15170168 No No 15169968 No No 15169938 No No 15169920 No No 15169919 No No 15169914 No No 15169911 No No 15169907 Yes Yes 15169904 No No

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[2] cell wall biosynthesis \(sensu Gram-negative Bacteria\)
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 11411704 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[3] clypeo-labral disc development
  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[4] determination of genital disc primordium
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 11702781 Yes No 11494318 Yes Yes 11245569 Yes Yes 7821227 No No

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[5] determination of wing disc primordium
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 8660883 No No 8620833 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[6] endothelial cell development
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 7 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15168350 No Yes 15166270 No Yes 15163622 No Yes 15162510 No No 15162095 No No 15161644 No Yes 15161350 Yes Yes 15161349 Yes Yes 15157618 Yes Yes 15156413 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[7] eye-antennal disc development
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 6 False positive 1 True negative 2 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15166150 Yes Yes 12829713 No No 11934850 No Yes 11806636 Yes Yes 11546747 Yes Yes 11171343 Yes Yes 10940621 No Yes 10545508 Yes Yes 9788434 Yes Yes 9753671 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[8] genital disc anterior/posterior pattern formation
  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[9] genital disc development
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 10 False positive 3 True negative 1 False negative 1

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 12466197 Yes Yes 11702781 Yes Yes 11494318 Yes Yes 11290302 No Yes 11245569 Yes Yes 11152632 Yes No 10446270 No Yes 9799432 Yes Yes 7790349 Yes Yes 7700356 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[10] genital disc pattern formation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 12919100 Yes No 11290302 No No 10446270 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: Yes


[11] hair cell differentiation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 7 False positive 0 True negative 1 False negative 3

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15129151 Yes Yes 15078079 No Yes 15078078 Yes Yes 15078073 Yes Yes 15078071 Yes Yes 14699969 Yes Yes 14698082 No No 14662166 Yes Yes 14593207 Yes Yes 14578428 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[12] haltere disc development
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 11874922 No No 11401396 No No 10751176 No No 10409512 No No 9347912 Yes No 9142491 No No 8806825 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[13] labial disc development
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 11526085 Yes No 10965682 No No 9331336 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: Yes


[14] larval cuticle pattern formation \(sensu Insecta\)
  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[15] leg disc anterior/posterior pattern formation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 7969450 Yes No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: Yes


[16] leg disc development
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 1 False positive 1 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15167667 No No 15148606 Yes Yes 15128656 No No 15013806 Yes Yes 14732398 Yes No 14668391 No No 14668390 Yes No 14597202 Yes No 14550411 No Yes 11960702 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[17] leg disc pattern formation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 1 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15148606 No No 14597202 Yes No 11960702 No Yes 10446270 No No 9521911 Yes No 9006073 No No 8951067 Yes Yes 8889525 No No 7969450 No No

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[18] mRNA 3'-end processing
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15169763 Yes No 15167896 Yes No 15158469 No No 15150262 Yes No 15125841 Yes No 15121841 Yes No 15121839 Yes No 15120999 Yes No 15109492 Yes No 15093190 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: Yes


[19] meiotic spindle elongation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 3 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 12906380 No No 12759375 Yes No 11534821 No No 11402192 Yes Yes 11069114 Yes Yes 10857582 Yes Yes 10775165 Yes Yes 9520321 Yes No 9055075 No No 9237224 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[20] negative regulation of DNA ligation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 1 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15166238 No No 15140576 No No 14970203 No No 14967736 No No 14679216 No No 14663072 No No 14623946 No Yes 14568931 No No 12928392 No No 12646620 No Yes

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[21] negative regulation of RNA metabolism
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15169854 No No 15169834 No No 15169830 No No 15169790 No No 15168054 No No 15166487 No No 15165992 No No 15163662 No No 15163064 No No 15162427 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[22] negative regulation of cell-matrix adhesion
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 2 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15075376 Yes Yes 14709717 No No 14666664 Yes No 14585964 No No 12970168 No No 12902987 No No 12879463 No No 12833140 Yes Yes 12832399 Yes Yes 12415742 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[23] negative regulation of cellular defense response
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 1 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 14967490 No Yes 14527726 No No 12704231 Yes No 11991642 No No 11975423 No Yes 11841848 No Yes 11729749 No Yes 11728812 No Yes 11602195 No Yes 10964544 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: Yes


[24] negative regulation of conjugation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 1 False positive 4 True negative 2 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 14761944 No Yes 14651627 No Yes 14563852 No Yes 12940985 No No 12816948 Yes Yes 12773487 No Yes 12631292 No Yes 12628336 No Yes 12600939 No Yes 12226386 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[25] negative regulation of endothelial cell proliferation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 2 True negative 1 False negative 1

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15037654 Yes Yes 14980508 No Yes 14970264 No No 14599874 Yes No 14576193 Yes No 12942550 Yes No 12855643 No No 12842839 No No 12773534 Yes Yes 12177246 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[26] negative regulation of lymphocyte activation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15134782 Yes Yes 15134778 Yes Yes 15115305 No No 15103247 No No 15067739 No No 15067058 No No 15031607 No No 15004161 No No 14972521 Yes Yes 14734616 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[27] negative regulation of sulfur metabolism
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15144379 No No 14996792 No No 14681972 No No 14663078 No No 14638413 No No 12890030 No No 12819857 No No 12813082 No No 12754263 No No 12423630 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[28] nucleoside salvage
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 2 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15165092 No No 15160509 No No 15157888 Yes No 15153709 No No 15149878 Yes Yes 15147376 No No 15139063 No No 15139055 No No 15133078 Yes No 15104248 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[29] nucleotide salvage
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 4 False positive 3 True negative 1 False negative 1

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15096815 No Yes 14981049 Yes No 14977562 Yes Yes 14975453 Yes No 14973196 Yes No 14769022 No No 14729341 Yes Yes 14687575 No Yes 14660729 No No 14658380 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[30] positive regulation of DNA ligation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15140576 No No 15101725 No No 15067048 No No 15023142 No No 14663072 No No 14662889 No No 14568931 No No 12944990 No No 12877896 No No 12676142 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[31] positive regulation of RNA metabolism
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15168054 No No 15166487 No No 15165715 No No 15165114 No No 15163734 No No 15163701 No No 15163064 No No 15162431 No No 15162427 No No 15162377 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[32] positive regulation of cell-matrix adhesion
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 14681058 No No 14519093 No No 12833140 Yes Yes 12745438 No No 11500940 No No 11496289 No No

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[33] positive regulation of conjugation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 1 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15003522 No No 14767675 No No 14697412 No Yes 14650439 Yes No 12826062 No No 12554766 No Yes 12549337 No No 12429984 No Yes 11827471 No Yes 11544353 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[34] positive regulation of endothelial cell proliferation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 1 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 1

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15048870 No No 15037654 No Yes 15015550 No No 14766757 Yes Yes 14599874 No No 12896824 No No 12798059 No Yes 12759411 Yes Yes 12570799 Yes No 11929782 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[35] positive regulation of lymphocyte activation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15153474 No No 15134782 No Yes 15134778 Yes Yes 15134773 No No 15128832 No No 15128811 No No 15128790 No No 15123741 Yes No 15122754 No No 15049426 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[36] positive regulation of retinoic acid receptor signaling pathway
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 14587095 No No 12749383 No No 12385002 No No 11934895 No No 11788593 No No 10928067 No No 10809236 No No 10644425 Yes No 10602018 No No 10200440 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: Yes


[37] positive regulation of sulfur metabolism
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 1 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 14663078 Yes No 14638413 No No 14511333 No No 12954816 No No 12948640 No No 12890030 Yes No 12819857 No No 12763067 No No 12754263 No No 11741847 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[38] prothoracic disc development
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 12013127 No No 9636080 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[39] regulation of DNA ligation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15166238 No No 15140576 No No 15134444 No No 15123585 No No 15120186 No No 15120183 No No 15101725 No No 15096457 No No 15090263 No No 15084713 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[40] regulation of RNA metabolism
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15170282 No No 15170231 No No 15170226 No No 15170111 No No 15170058 No No 15170054 No No 15169966 No No 15169948 No No 15169942 No No 15169937 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[41] regulation of carbohydrate biosynthesis
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15169936 No No 15169745 No No 15169657 No No 15168733 No No 15168731 No No 15168606 No No 15168092 No No 15166487 No No 15165995 No No 15164316 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[42] regulation of cell-matrix adhesion
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 3 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15157155 Yes Yes 15130580 Yes Yes 15075376 Yes Yes 15047871 No No 15033989 No No 15028778 No No 15006643 Yes Yes 15004000 Yes Yes 15003926 Yes Yes 14998999 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[43] regulation of endothelial cell proliferation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15166495 Yes Yes 15158909 Yes Yes 15158908 Yes No 15158160 Yes No 15157674 Yes No 15154008 No No 15151905 Yes No 15143962 Yes No 15107818 No Yes 15090731 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[44] regulation of lymphocyte activation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 3 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15163118 Yes Yes 15161006 Yes No 15161003 No No 15157024 No No 15155620 No Yes 15153474 No No 15140570 No Yes 15134788 No Yes 15134782 Yes Yes 15134778 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[45] regulation of sulfur amino acid metabolism
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 2 False positive 1 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15066131 No No 15059259 No No 15052410 No No 15030315 No No 15028699 No No 15020643 No No 14998549 No No 14992268 Yes Yes 14972351 Yes Yes 14739061 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[46] regulation of tube diameter
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 2 False positive 1 True negative 0 False negative 1

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 14734539 Yes No 14720620 No No 12973360 Yes Yes 12934611 No No 12881206 No No 12729556 No Yes 12605269 No No 11993017 No No 10887083 Yes Yes 9220840 No Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[47] sodium-independent organic anion transport
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15159445 No No 15102942 No No 15100168 No No 15078096 No No 15075193 No No 15037815 No No 15010355 No No 14993604 Yes Yes 14984259 No No 14762099 No No

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[48] somatic stem cell division
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15138585 No No 15138252 No No 15128675 No Yes 15107851 No No 15105369 No No 15068898 No Yes 15005568 No Yes 15005248 No No 14704180 No Yes 14653996 No Yes

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[49] spindle elongation
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 15 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 1

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15126629 Yes Yes 15075284 Yes Yes 14657278 Yes Yes 14534135 Yes Yes 12972644 Yes Yes 12956950 Yes Yes 12802083 Yes Yes 12658461 Yes Yes 12636915 Yes Yes 12591913 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[50] stem cell division
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15170211 Yes Yes 15170171 No No 15170169 No No 15170168 No No 15169968 Yes No 15169841 No No 15169805 No No 15169789 No No 15168599 No No 15168588 No No

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[51] synaptic vesicle docking during exocytosis
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 1 False negative 6

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 14983476 Yes No 14622203 Yes No 14600261 Yes No 12973353 Yes Yes 12914956 Yes No 12151511 No No 12124443 Yes No 11865051 Yes No 11460165 Yes No 11068331 Yes No

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[52] tungsten incorporation into metallo-sulfur cluster
  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[53] vitamin A biosynthesis
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15166231 No No 15162133 No No 15161698 No No 15161031 No No 15158163 No No 15157739 No No 15150131 No No 15139019 No No 15132822 No No 15127614 No No

  * automatically validated: No
  * manually validated: No


[54] wing disc development
  Sentence Validation   details

Type of results Sentences True positive 5 False positive 0 True negative 2 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15073155 No No 15062563 Yes No 15019513 No No 14735139 No No 14732398 Yes Yes 14668391 Yes No 14660540 Yes Yes 14550411 No No 12871911 Yes Yes 12835386 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


[55] wing disc pattern formation
  Sentence Validation

Type of results Sentences True positive 0 False positive 0 True negative 0 False negative 0

  Abstract Validation

PMID Curator System 15073155 No No 12900462 No Yes 12361606 Yes No 12217317 Yes No 12183378 No No 11450809 No No 11171396 Yes No 11171395 Yes No 11136981 Yes No 11023875 Yes Yes

  * automatically validated: Yes
  * manually validated: Yes


* Total terms: 55
* Total abstracts: 448
* Total sentences: 123

* Summary of sentence validation
  - True positive: 69
  - False positive: 27
  - True negative: 12
  - False negative: 15
  > Precision: 71.9 %
  > Recall: 82.1 %

* Summary of abstract validation
  - True positive: 94
  - False positive: 56
  - True negative: 238
  - False negative: 60
  > Precision: 62.7 %
  > Recall: 61.0 %

* Total terms automatically curated by system: 32 (58.2 %)
* Total terms manually curated by curator: 38 (69.1 %)